Pop’s Seafood Shack & Grill: Part Deux (Electric Boogaloo)

Pop’s Seafood Shack & Grill
15 Railroad Place
Island Park, NY 11558

The last time my wife and I went to Pop’s we had a not-so-great experience. You can read about it here, but basically we left without eating anything. Our original 1/2 hour wait time kept increasing by 30 minutes. After an hour and a half we were told “it could be another 30 minutes.” At that point we were so hungry and just couldn’t wait any longer. Besides, we got tired of watching friends of the owners taking our tables (an observation also made by other patrons.) But, to make things fair – Pop’s just opened and it was obvious they didn’t know what they were doing and were very overwhelmed.

I wrote about this experience and it turns out many of you went through the same thing. Based on the comments, those who actually got to eat the food had an even worse experience! So why go back after all the negativity? Well, I have to admit, I am attracted to Pop’s decor, effort and strange waterfront location. It just feels right to give them another try and proper review. Here I go:

ATMOSPHERE: My first review already talks about the decor – the place looks great, nothing else to add. For those who hate crowds and idiots, Monday nights at Pop’s is for you – no bouncers and plenty of seats are available. Our wait time was zero seconds and you can’t beat that. As far as music is concerned (for those who care), it was a mix of The Beatles, Cyndi Lauper, The Bangles (just another manic monday?), The Police and some wedding music. That sort of stuff.

THE FOOD: You don’t go to Pop’s for gourmet; this place looks like a seafood and burger joint, so that’s what we ordered.

For starters, my wife got the Beach Salad (pineapple, strawberries, blue cheese, arugula, lettuce, horseradish dressing, other stuff). Sounds sort of good, right? Well, the lettuce was rotten. Our waitress, who was extremely nice and apologetic brought out a fresh one. So was it tasty? My wife said it was “Meh..”  Not a good way to start…

Out comes the bowl of mussels. Again, my wife said they were “meh..” and added, “Not bad, but I can get fresh mussels at the farmer’s market and cook them better.” She didn’t seem that impressed. I don’t eat seafood, so I have no say on this matter.

I ordered the Butcher Block Burger topped with onions, jalapeños and feta cheese. The burger was dry with no flavor. It was basically just a large piece of meat that was overcooked. It reminded me of a hockey puck. I generally like a crispier bun and this was like wonder bread. It was disappointing. Burgers are probably one of their most ordered items, so it seems like a no-brainer to get those at least right.  I opted for a house salad instead of fries because I’m just trying to watch what I eat. That was pretty good. Pretty simple and the dressing was tasty. I probably should have put some of the salad in my burger. Maybe that would of help. Hey, at least it all looks good in the photo:

THE SERVICE: Our waitress was extremely nice. After the salad incident, she kept asking if everything was ok and was paying us extra attention (perhaps she knew I was the evil seabythecity food critic?).

A FEW NOTES ON THE MENU: I want to point out that the current menu online is different than what is at the restaurant. Our waitress told us the menu was revamped after they noticed more people were ordering finger foods. All the main entrées were eliminated and the current (as of sept 13th, 2011) online menu doesn’t reflect these changes yet. I know all about being lazy updating websites, so I can’t argue with that. (This is subject to change. If you see a menu online that has no entrées – then it’s been updated.)

THE FUTURE: I asked the waitress what was going to happen to Pop’s once it gets cold out – being that the dining area is completely outdoors. She said  they’ll stay open until Halloween. Then they will close for two months and reopen with tents and heaters. I’m guessing they’re going to try to go after the New Year’s Eve crowd; A big booze-money opportunity that can’t be wasted..

THE VERDICT:  Sorry Pop’s, but your food is mediocre at best. I love the decor and I give credit for improving a forgotten waterfront, but that’s not enough to draw me back, at least for a while. Pop’s needs to figure out the menu and what kind of place it wants to be. My advice for them is to perfect the simple stuff: Burgers and simple seafood dishes. I see this all the time in Kitchen Nightmares, so I’m an expert (rolling my eyes); don’t get too fancy, just stay simple and have the best. For now I’m going to add Pop’s to my long list of mediocre restaurants in the area. I really am rooting for you though….

(Read my first review – Pop’s Seafood Shack & Grill – Island Park)


Please read the terms of service before you comment.


13 thoughts on “Pop’s Seafood Shack & Grill: Part Deux (Electric Boogaloo)”

  1. The first time I went, i thought the food was pretty good. The 2nd time it was eh, but I thought the mussels were pretty amazing. I’m glad they switched to just appetizers, as they were a lot better than the meals we got the 1st time. I love the decor there and I hope they do well!

  2. The first time I went the wait time was 3 hours, this was during the week and after 7:30. The second time, also during the week, the wait time was an hour, the food was nothing special. The waitress was pretty good looking though.

  3. Maybe you should try a Tuesday! I was there last night with 9 friends. Loved the atmosphere also. The only food complaint was with the tuna. Mussels were good. Two different lobster
    rolls were very good. The rest of us had the burgers. I also prefer a different kind of roll but the burger was pretty good – definitely not dry! If anything it was toward the greasy side – not a bad thing 🙂 Hope Pop’s works out their inconsistencies because I would like to see them succeed.

  4. IMHO, this place isn’t about the food. it’s really unique hang out spot that actually spent the time to get the decor and vibe down….a real rarity for our area. food should be considered no more than something to coat your belly with while you imbibe adult beverages. the times i’ve been there, i’ve loved the vibe, loved the mix of people and was happy to lay down $5 to get a cheeseburger on the spot from the outdoor grill. if this place makes it, it won’t be because they’re a great dinning experience, it will be because they’re a great bar. i just hope it doesn’t get too overrun by the crowd from barnum island.

  5. I’ve been there a few times and the lobster rolls seem the way to go; everyone I’ve been with has loved them.

    However I still can’t get past the guido trash that hangs out there, it really spoils it for me.

  6. John, I agree with you. That’s sort of what I meant when I said they need to figure out what kind of place it wants to be. And if they want to serve food, they should keep it simple and not get fancy. Food places can service on alcohol alone, but what about on a quiet monday night when the partrons just want a nice meal.

  7. I go there because its a cool spot and to get drinks. I never thought of it as a dinner place. that being said i met the head chef and he was really nice, and experienced, he is putting out a lot of food and if you choose right you will enjoy it. for example the lobster rolls are awesome.

Comments are closed.